Lumbar Disc Replacement for Lower Back Pain
If a damaged disc in your lower back has been the source of pain that hasn't let up — and fusion surgery isn't something you're eager to sign up for — disc replacement is worth a real conversation. It's a same-day-to-overnight procedure, and unlike fusion, it's built to keep your spine moving the way it's supposed to.
Board Certified
Neurosurgeon
15+ Years
Experience
5000+
Procedures Performed
Get In Touch
Contact us today to schedule your consultation and take the first step toward relief.
"*" indicates required fields
This form is intended for scheduling purposes only and is not a HIPAA-compliant form. Please avoid sharing any sensitive medical information. By submitting, you consent to being contacted using the information provided.
What Is Lumbar Disc Replacement?
A lot of patients come in already familiar with spinal fusion — and assume that's their only surgical option once a disc has worn out or herniated badly enough. Disc replacement is the alternative most people haven't heard of, and it works on a different principle entirely.
Discs sit between the bones of your spine and act as cushions, allowing each segment to bend, twist, and absorb load. When one breaks down — from degeneration, injury, or a herniation that hasn't responded to anything else — it stops doing its job and starts generating pain instead. Fusion solves that by locking the two bones together permanently. Disc replacement takes a different route: it removes the damaged disc and puts an artificial one in its place, so the segment keeps moving instead of being fused solid.
Here's how we explain it to patients who come into our Falls Church and Alexandria offices:
This is a surgery performed to treat a damaged disc in the lower back that is causing pain. Instead of fusing the bones together, the damaged disc is replaced with an artificial disc that is designed to maintain motion in the spine.
During the procedure, the surgeon removes the damaged disc and replaces it with an implant that mimics the natural movement of a healthy disc. Imaging such as MRI and X-rays are used before surgery to plan the procedure. The goal is to relieve pain while preserving motion and improving function. The procedure takes approximately 30 minutes and you typically go home the same day or the following day. Patients with a desk job typically return to work within 5 days. If you have a more labor-intensive job, please ask your doctor when you may return.
30 Minutes
Same Day or Next Day
General Anesthesia
5 Days
Who Does This Procedure Help?
Disc replacement is most appropriate when one specific lumbar disc has broken down and is the clear source of pain — not when the problem is spread across multiple levels or tied to bone-on-bone arthritis. These are the diagnoses we see most often in patients considering this surgery.
01
Degenerative Disc Disease
When a single disc in the lower back has lost height and hydration over time, it can become a constant source of mechanical pain, especially with sitting or bending. Disc replacement addresses the worn disc directly while letting that segment keep moving.
02
Herniated Disc That Hasn't Responded to Conservative Care
Some herniations don't improve with injections, physical therapy, or time. When the disc itself is the problem and other treatments haven't worked, replacing it can resolve pain that's been resistant to everything else.
03
Chronic Discogenic Low Back Pain
Pain that originates from inside the disc — rather than a pinched nerve — often shows up as deep, central low back pain that worsens with prolonged sitting or standing. This is one of the clearest indications for disc replacement.
04
Single-Level Disc Collapse
When imaging shows one disc has noticeably narrowed compared to the levels above and below it, that segment is often carrying the disproportionate share of your pain — and is typically the best candidate for a replacement procedure.
05
Patients Wanting to Avoid Fusion
Some patients are simply not candidates for, or not interested in, a fusion that permanently locks two vertebrae together. Disc replacement gives them a surgical option that addresses the damaged disc while preserving the segment's natural motion.
06
Younger, Active Patients
Because fusion eliminates motion at a segment — which can shift extra stress to the levels above and below over the years — younger and more active patients are often better served by an implant that keeps that segment moving naturally.
Ready to Move Without Pain?
Find out whether Lumbar Percutaneous Discectomy is the right treatment for your symptoms.
What Lumbar Disc Replacement Can Do for You
For patients who've already tried injections, medication, and physical therapy without lasting relief — and who'd rather avoid permanently fusing their spine — this is usually the next conversation worth having.
Treats the Disc Without Locking the Spine
Fusion solves disc pain by eliminating motion at that segment. Disc replacement solves it while keeping that segment moving — closer to how your spine worked before the disc wore out.
Built to Mimic Natural Movement
The implant isn't a static spacer. It's engineered to bend and rotate similarly to a healthy disc, so the segment above and below doesn't have to compensate for a joint that no longer moves.
Imaging-Guided Planning, Every Time
We review MRI and X-ray imaging closely before ever stepping into the operating room. The exact disc level, implant sizing, and surgical approach are all planned out ahead of time — not figured out on the fly.
A Short Procedure with a Fast Path Home
The surgery itself takes about 30 minutes. Most patients go home the same day or the next morning — not the multi-day hospital stay people sometimes picture when they hear "spine surgery."
Designed for a Quicker Return to Work
Patients in desk jobs are often back to work within about five days. If your job is more physical, we'll walk you through a timeline that fits the demands of what you do.
May Reduce Stress on Neighboring Discs
Because the treated segment keeps moving instead of fusing solid, the discs above and below it may be spared some of the extra wear that can follow a fusion over time.
Key Benefits
Targeted Relief at the Source
Rather than masking pain, the procedure addresses the disc material that's actually compressing the nerve, which is why relief tends to be more direct than with medication alone.
No Cutting of Muscle or Bone
Because the spine is accessed through a needle rather than an incision, there's no muscle dissection and no bone removal — a major reason recovery tends to move faster.
Minimal Scarring
The access point is roughly the size of a needle puncture, not a surgical incision, which means little to no visible scarring afterward.
Faster Return to Activity
Most patients are walking the same day and resuming light daily activities within a week or two, well ahead of the typical timeline for open surgery.
Spinal Stability Is Preserved
Because no bone, ligament, or facet joint is removed, the natural movement of the spinal segment stays intact — no fusion is needed.
What Happens During the Procedure
Positioning & Anesthesia
You're positioned on your stomach, and the skin over the treatment area is numbed with local anesthetic. Light sedation is typically used so you stay comfortable and relaxed throughout.
Imaging-Guided Needle Placement
Using real-time x-ray (fluoroscopy), a thin needle is guided to the targeted disc through a small natural opening between the spinal structures, avoiding the need for any incision.
Accessing the Disc
The needle is advanced into the outer portion of the disc using a posterolateral approach, reaching the herniated material without disturbing the surrounding muscle, bone, or nerve.
Confirming Position
Before any tissue is removed, imaging confirms the needle is exactly where it needs to be. This step is what keeps the procedure precise and safe.
Removing or Decompressing Disc Material
A small amount of the herniated nucleus material is removed or decompressed through the needle. This is the core of the procedure — once pressure inside the disc drops, pressure on the nerve drops with it.
Confirming Decompression
Imaging is used again to confirm the nerve has more room and that no additional disc material is contributing to the compression.
Going Home
A bandage is placed over the small puncture site — no stitches are usually needed. After a short observation period, most patients go home within a couple of hours. No overnight hospital stay is required.
What Makes Us Different
Patients come to us from Falls Church, Alexandria, and across Northern Virginia because we actually take the time to figure out whether disc replacement — or something else entirely — is the right call before we recommend anything.
A Neurosurgeon Performing Your Surgery
Dr. Buchholz is a fellowship-trained, board-certified neurosurgeon with extensive experience in both motion-preserving and fusion-based spine surgery. You're not choosing between a surgeon who only does one approach.
Imaging Reviewed in Detail Before Surgery
Your MRI and X-rays are studied closely to confirm the disc replacement is the right fit for your anatomy and your specific level of damage — not just assumed because it's the procedure you asked about.
We Look at You, Not Just the Scan
Imaging tells part of the story. Your symptoms, your job, your activity level, and what you've already tried tell us the rest. The surgical plan is built around your situation specifically.
Honest Conversations About Fusion vs. Replacement
Not every patient is a candidate for disc replacement, and we'll tell you plainly if fusion is the better option for your case — rather than steering you toward whichever procedure sounds more appealing.
Two Offices in Northern Virginia
Falls Church and Alexandria — both easy to reach without driving into DC. Pre-op visits, surgery, and follow-up care are coordinated through the same team throughout.
Most Insurance Plans Accepted
We work with most major insurers and offer straightforward cash-pay pricing. Our team will help you understand what's covered before you commit to anything.
What Recovery Looks Like
Recovery from disc replacement tends to move faster than fusion recovery, since there's no bone-healing process to wait on. Here's what the typical path looks like.
Day of Surgery
Same-Day or Overnight Stay
The procedure itself takes around 30 minutes. Most patients go home that same day; some stay one night for observation. Either way, you'll need someone to drive you home.
Days 1–5
Easing Back Into Daily Life
Walking is encouraged early — it actually helps recovery. Patients with desk jobs are typically cleared to return to work within about five days. Heavier lifting and strenuous activity are held off during this window.
Weeks 1–4
Building Activity Back Up Gradually
Soreness around the incision continues to settle. Most patients are walking comfortably and resuming light daily activities without much restriction. Physical therapy, if recommended, often starts during this stretch.
Weeks 4–12
Returning to Full Activity
This is when most patients return to more demanding work and physical activity, guided by how they're progressing rather than a fixed calendar date. Labor-intensive jobs typically need a longer runway — we'll set that timeline with you directly.
Beyond 12 Weeks
Settling Into the New Normal
By this point, most patients have returned to the activities that mattered to them before surgery, with the treated segment continuing to move as designed.
Is This Right for You?
Disc replacement works best when a single damaged disc — not widespread degeneration or arthritis — is the clear driver of your pain. These are the situations where it tends to make sense.
Good Candidates for This Procedure
- Chronic low back pain traced to one specific disc on MRI
- Pain that hasn't improved with injections, medication, or physical therapy
- Otherwise healthy disc levels above and below the damaged one
- Interested in a surgical option that preserves motion rather than fusing the spine
- Younger or more active patients concerned about long-term stress on adjacent discs
No significant facet joint arthritis at the affected level
A Few Things We Check First
- Significant facet joint arthritis or bone-on-bone changes may favor fusion instead
- Prior spine surgery at the same level needs careful evaluation
- Osteoporosis or significantly weakened bone can affect implant suitability
- Active infection anywhere in the body needs to clear up first
- We go through all of this at your consultation — nothing is assumed
Come in. We'll look at your imaging, hear your history, and give you a straight answer — whether that's disc replacement, fusion, or something else entirely.
Expert Spine Surgeon
Dr. Avery L. Buchholz is a board-certified neurosurgeon with fellowship training in complex spine surgery. With over 15 years of experience and 5,000+ procedures performed, he specializes in both minimally invasive and complex surgical techniques.
His expertise spans the full spectrum of spine care, from non-surgical interventions to advanced reconstructive procedures, always prioritizing patient safety and optimal outcomes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get answers to common questions about our practice and procedures
How is disc replacement different from spinal fusion?
Fusion permanently joins two vertebrae together so that segment no longer moves. Disc replacement removes the damaged disc and puts in an implant designed to move the way a healthy disc would. Both treat disc-related pain — the difference is whether the segment keeps moving afterward.
Will I feel anything during the procedure?
No. The surgery is performed under general anesthesia, so you're fully asleep and won't feel anything during the procedure itself. Some soreness around the incision is normal afterward as you recover.
How long does the surgery take?
The procedure itself takes approximately 30 minutes. Total time at the surgical facility will be longer once you account for prep and recovery monitoring, but the surgery itself is relatively brief.
Will I need to stay in the hospital?
Most patients go home the same day. Some stay one night for observation, depending on how the procedure goes and how you're feeling afterward. We'll let you know what to expect ahead of time based on your specific case.
When can I go back to work?
Patients with desk jobs typically return within about five days. If your job involves physical labor, lifting, or a lot of standing, your timeline will likely be longer — your doctor will set a return date based on what your job actually requires.
Am I a candidate for disc replacement, or would I need fusion?
That depends on what your imaging shows. Disc replacement works best when one disc is damaged and the surrounding joints and bone are otherwise healthy. If there's significant arthritis or bone-on-bone changes at that level, fusion may be the better fit. We'll review your MRI and X-rays in detail before recommending either.
Will my insurance cover this procedure?
Most major insurance plans cover lumbar disc replacement when there's documented medical necessity. We accept most major plans and also offer cash-pay pricing. Our team can help verify your coverage before your procedure date.
How long does the artificial disc last?
These implants are designed for long-term use, and many patients do well with them for years to come. As with any implant, we'll go over expected durability and what to watch for during your consultation.
Our Locations
Serving patients across VA and the DC area
Falls Church, VA
6400 Arlington Blvd, Suite 710
Open
Alexandria, VA
6244A Little River Turnpike
Open
Richmond, VA
Address coming soon
Opening Soon
Charlottesville, VA
Address coming soon
Opening Soon
Washington, DC
Address coming soon
Opening Soon
Get In Touch
Contact us today to schedule your consultation and take the first step toward relief.
Address
6244 Little River Turnpike, Suite 101
Alexandria, VA 22312
Phone
FAX
Office Hours
Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
This form is intended for scheduling purposes only and is not a HIPAA-compliant form. Please avoid sharing any sensitive medical information.
By submitting, you consent to being contacted using the information provided.
Follow Us